Investigative Journalism and Learning Hub - BCS Strata Management ignored request to provide details of inequitable water and gas usage reimbursements to selective SP52948 owners on 12 May 2013

Welcome to the blog of NSW strata investigative journalism

From: SP52948 owner
To: Peter Bone BCS Strata Management
CC: Bruce Copland, Moses Levitt, Stan Pogorelsky, Jeffery Wang, Maureen McDonald
Subject: OFFICIAL REQUEST FOR RESPONSE for EGM 2013 and CTTT: SP52948 Water and Gas Reimbursements in FY 2013
Date: 12/5/13, 12:01 am

Hello,

Before I publish it for all owners and give to the CTTT, I am officially asking you to respond as per:

NSW Strata Schemes Management Act 1996
  Division 2 – Members and office holders of the executive committee   22 What are the functions of the secretary of an owners corporation?
  (a) to prepare and distribute minutes of meetings of the owners corporation of the minutes of any meeting of the owners corporation at the next such meeting,
  (c) to enable the inspection of documents on behalf of the owners corporation in accordance with section 108,
  (d) to answer communications addressed to the owners corporation
  ...

I do not have much patience or time to wait for your response. It should come immediately since it will have to be given to all owners for EGM 2013 and the CTTT.

I have just calculated water and gas reimbursements for FY 2003, 2004, and eight-month period in 2013. Your office still owns me the data for other missing years, but that will certainly come in time.

a) Please give me the name of the person(s) who approved these rebates in FY 2013 when some owners claimed water and gas reimbursements for periods as far behind as 2011 or charged excessive "fees"?

At the present time, 16 owners in townhouses charged for water and gas reimbursements around 12% of what the whole complex (218 owners) spent together on common property and buildings in the first six months of FY 2013.

The figure for gas usage for the whole complex is only six-month calculation, whilst the water is for eight-month calculation.

16 owners who claim water and gas reimbursements represent only 7.34% of the total number of owners.

Just one single townhouse owner claimed $1,166.69 for private water expenses in the first half of FY 2013, and if we add their gas usage of $251.72, this owner claimed already $1,418.41 alone!

b) Based on the "approved" Special-By Law, where are the equitable rights of all owners (especially all lot owners in the buildings) to share the costs?

The summary of water and gas invoices in FY 2013 show extreme abuse of common funds by some townhouse owners and no member of the EC and the Strata Manager took any actions to correct it.

I do support equitable rights for all owners, but certainly not abuse of these kinds. Once we remove the Special By-Laws for these reimbursements, if owners really want to share the costs, we will have to come with some better calculations how to implement them.

The one that the EC "implemented" for the last 14 years is criminal. Not only all 192 owners in the buildings are abused, but even those townhouse owners who use water and gas lightly and those who do not claim it at all.